Statement of Affairs (SoA) in Insolvency
A Statement of Affairs, commonly referred to as an SoA, is a formal financial statement showing the financial position of an insolvent company at a specified date.
It provides creditors and the appointed Insolvency Practitioner with a clear summary of the company's assets, liabilities, creditors and estimated financial deficiency.
Importantly, a Statement of Affairs is not simply an optional document prepared for information purposes. In a Creditors' Voluntary Liquidation and in most Administrations, its preparation is a statutory requirement.
Why is a Statement of Affairs required?
The purpose of a Statement of Affairs is to provide transparency regarding the company's financial position at the commencement of formal insolvency proceedings.
It enables creditors and the Insolvency Practitioner to understand:
- what assets the company owns;
- the estimated value of those assets;
- what liabilities are owed by the company;
- who the company's creditors are;
- whether creditors hold security over company assets;
- the estimated amount available to different classes of creditor; and
- the overall estimated deficiency or surplus.
The Statement of Affairs also provides an important starting point for the Insolvency Practitioner when assessing the company's financial position and administering the insolvency estate.
Statement of Affairs in a Creditors' Voluntary Liquidation
Where a company enters Creditors' Voluntary Liquidation ("CVL"), the directors are under a statutory duty to prepare a Statement of Affairs.
Section 99 of the Insolvency Act 1986 requires the directors to make out a statement in the prescribed form as to the affairs of the company and send it to the company's creditors.
Under the current legislation, this must be done before the end of the period of seven days beginning with the day after the company passes its resolution for voluntary winding up.
The Statement of Affairs must also be verified by a statement of truth.
The detailed requirements are contained within Part 6 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016, particularly Rules 6.3 to 6.7. Rule 6.14 also requires a copy of the Statement of Affairs to be delivered to creditors not later than the business day before the decision date for nominating a liquidator. Both the section 99 deadline and the applicable creditor-decision deadline must be met.
Rule 6.3 provides, amongst other things, that the Statement of Affairs must relate to a specified date which is not more than 14 days before the date of the resolution to wind up the company.
Accordingly, the preparation and provision of a Statement of Affairs in a CVL is a legal obligation placed upon the directors, rather than simply an administrative requirement imposed by the proposed Liquidator.
Statement of Affairs in an Administration
A Statement of Affairs may also be required when a company enters Administration.
Paragraph 47 of Schedule B1 to the Insolvency Act 1986 requires the Administrator, as soon as reasonably practicable following appointment, to give notice requiring one or more relevant persons to provide a Statement of Affairs. This is subject to the power to revoke the requirement under paragraph 48.
The legislation specifically requires the statement to include particulars of the company's property, debts and liabilities, together with details of its creditors and any security held by those creditors. The Statement of Affairs must also be verified by a statement of truth.
The detailed procedure is contained within Rules 3.28 to 3.34 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
Where a person is formally required to provide the Statement of Affairs, it must normally be delivered to the Administrator before the end of the period of 11 days beginning with the day the notice is received. The Administrator has statutory powers to revoke the requirement or extend the period for compliance.
In most cases, the persons required to provide the information will include one or more of the company's directors or other persons who possess sufficient knowledge of the company's financial affairs.
What information is included in a Statement of Affairs?
The precise format depends upon the insolvency procedure, but a Statement of Affairs will normally contain detailed information concerning the company's assets and liabilities.
This will commonly include:
Company details
The Statement of Affairs identifies the company and specifies the date to which the financial information relates.
Company assets
The company's assets are identified together with their:
- book value; and
- estimated realisable value.
Depending upon the circumstances, assets may include:
- cash at bank;
- cash in hand;
- property;
- plant and machinery;
- motor vehicles;
- stock and work in progress;
- trade debtors;
- investments;
- intellectual property;
- director or connected-party loan accounts; and
- other amounts due to the company.
The estimated realisable value may be materially different from the value shown in the company's accounting records because the purpose of the Statement of Affairs is to provide an estimate of what may actually be recovered for creditors.
Secured creditors
Details must be provided of creditors holding security over the company's assets.
This can include:
- the identity of the secured creditor;
- the amount owed;
- the nature of the security;
- the date upon which the security was granted; and
- the estimated value of the security.
Preferential and other creditors
The Statement of Affairs provides information regarding the company's different categories of liabilities and the amounts estimated to be due.
This can include amounts due to:
- employees and former employees;
- HM Revenue & Customs;
- landlords;
- suppliers;
- lenders;
- customers and consumers;
- directors;
- connected parties; and
- other persons or organisations to whom the company is indebted.
Employees, former employees and consumers are creditors where sums are owed to them by the company and must therefore be taken into account when the company's creditor position is recorded.
Unsecured creditors
A Statement of Affairs will normally contain details of the company's unsecured creditors.
The term creditor is not limited to trade suppliers, banks or commercial lenders. It can also include:
- employees and former employees who are owed wages, holiday pay, redundancy-related sums or other employment liabilities;
- consumer creditors, including customers who have paid deposits, advance payments or other sums for goods or services which have not been supplied;
- landlords;
- HM Revenue & Customs;
- professional advisers;
- directors and connected parties; and
- any other individual or organisation to whom money is owed.
The information required may include:
- the creditor's name;
- postal address;
- amount owed;
- details of any security held, where applicable;
- the date any security was granted; and
- the estimated value of that security.
Section 99 of the Insolvency Act 1986 requires the Statement of Affairs in a CVL to show particulars of the company's assets, debts and liabilities, together with the names and addresses of its creditors and details of securities held by them.
Accordingly, where an employee, former employee or consumer is owed money by the company, that person is a creditor for insolvency purposes and their claim must be properly reflected in the Statement of Affairs and associated creditor information.
Employees and former employees
Employees and former employees may be creditors of the company in respect of amounts such as:
- unpaid wages or salary;
- accrued holiday pay;
- notice pay;
- redundancy entitlements;
- expenses; and
- other employment-related amounts.
Depending upon the nature of the claim, some employee claims may qualify as preferential claims, whilst other elements may rank as unsecured claims.
The fact that the creditor is an employee or former employee does not remove the requirement to record the liability. Their claim remains part of the company's overall creditor position.
Consumer creditors
Consumers may also be creditors of an insolvent company.
Examples can include customers who have:
- paid a deposit for goods which have not been supplied;
- paid in advance for services which have not been provided;
- purchased vouchers, memberships or subscriptions which cannot be honoured;
- paid for an event, service or product which the company is unable to provide; or
- otherwise become entitled to repayment of money by the company.
Such individuals are creditors of the company and their claims must be taken into account when preparing the Statement of Affairs.
Protection of employee and consumer creditor information
Although employees, former employees and consumers are creditors and their claims must be included in the insolvency records, the Insolvency Rules contain specific protections concerning the public disclosure of certain personal information.
In particular, where creditors are:
- employees or former employees; or
- consumers who are creditors because they paid for goods or services in advance,
the individual creditor particulars required by the Rules must be set out in separate schedules. Those schedules must not be included in the version of the Statement of Affairs delivered to Companies House for public filing. The statement itself records the number of creditors and the total debt for each of these two categories.
This distinction is important.
It does not mean that those creditors can be omitted from the company's creditor records or from the financial assessment of the insolvency. Their claims must still be identified, quantified and properly recorded.
Rather, the separate-schedule provisions are intended to protect certain personal information from unnecessary public disclosure while still ensuring that the Insolvency Practitioner and other persons entitled to receive the information have the details required to administer the insolvency correctly.
Shareholders
For a CVL, the Insolvency Rules also require details of the company's shareholders, including their names and postal addresses, the type and number of shares held and relevant information concerning the amounts called up on those shares.
Estimated deficiency or surplus
The Statement of Affairs provides an overall picture of the company's estimated financial position after taking account of its assets and liabilities.
It will normally identify the estimated deficiency to creditors and, where applicable, the estimated deficiency or surplus attributable to members.
Is personal information allowed to appear on a Statement of Affairs?
Yes. The fact that a Statement of Affairs contains personal information does not, by itself, mean that there has been a breach of UK data-protection legislation.
The Insolvency Act 1986 and the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 expressly require certain information to be included within a Statement of Affairs and require that information to be supplied to specified persons.
This can include personal information concerning:
- individual trade creditors;
- employees and former employees;
- consumer creditors;
- directors;
- shareholders;
- landlords;
- sole traders; and
- other individuals to whom the company owes money.
The legislation specifically requires information concerning creditors, including names, postal addresses, amounts owed and details of security where applicable.
Under Article 6(1)(c) of the UK GDPR, personal information may lawfully be processed where the processing is necessary for compliance with a legal obligation to which the controller is subject.
Accordingly, where directors, an Insolvency Practitioner or another relevant person includes, processes or circulates personal information because the insolvency legislation requires them to do so, consent from the individual concerned is not required as the basis for that processing.
The statutory obligations imposed by the Insolvency Act 1986 and the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 provide the legal basis for the necessary processing and disclosure.
This applies equally where the creditor is an employee, former employee or consumer creditor.
Does the Data Protection Act 2018 prevent a Statement of Affairs being circulated?
No. The Data Protection Act 2018 and UK GDPR do not prevent compliance with statutory insolvency obligations.
Where insolvency legislation requires information to be provided to creditors, the Insolvency Practitioner, Companies House or another prescribed recipient, the necessary disclosure can be made on the basis of compliance with that legal obligation.
This can include creditor information relating to individuals, including employees, former employees and consumers.
However, this does not mean that data-protection requirements can be disregarded altogether. Information should still be:
- relevant to the statutory purpose;
- limited to what is required;
- accurate so far as reasonably possible;
- handled securely; and
- disclosed only in accordance with the applicable insolvency legislation and other legal requirements.
There are also specific protections within the Insolvency Rules concerning certain creditor information.
For example, where creditors are employees or former employees, or consumers claiming amounts paid in advance for goods or services, the individual creditor particulars required by the Rules must be contained in separate schedules. Those schedules must be excluded from the version delivered to the Registrar of Companies for public filing.
However, those individuals remain creditors of the company. Their liabilities must still be recorded and the relevant information must still be provided to those persons who are legally entitled or required to receive it for the purposes of the insolvency proceedings.
The insolvency legislation therefore expressly recognises both:
- the need for complete creditor information to be available for the proper administration of the insolvency; and
- the need to protect certain personal information from unnecessary public disclosure.
Is completing a Statement of Affairs optional?
No.
Where the statutory provisions apply, preparation of the Statement of Affairs is a legal requirement.
In a Creditors' Voluntary Liquidation, the obligation is imposed upon the directors by section 99 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
In an Administration, an Administrator may formally require relevant persons to prepare and submit a Statement of Affairs pursuant to paragraph 47 of Schedule B1 to the Insolvency Act 1986.
A director should therefore ensure that the information supplied is complete and accurate and that reasonable enquiries are undertaken where necessary.
This includes ensuring that all categories of creditor are properly identified, not simply trade creditors. Employees, former employees, consumer creditors, HM Revenue & Customs, landlords, lenders, directors, connected parties and other persons to whom money is owed must all be considered.
The Statement of Affairs is verified by a statement of truth, emphasising the importance of providing accurate information.
Why accuracy matters
The Statement of Affairs is an important statutory document which will be relied upon by creditors and the Insolvency Practitioner.
Directors should therefore take reasonable care to ensure that:
- all known assets are disclosed;
- realistic estimated realisable values are provided;
- all known creditors are included;
- employees and former employees who are owed money are included;
- consumer creditors, including customers who have paid deposits or advance payments, are included;
- creditor balances are as accurate as reasonably possible;
- secured liabilities are properly identified;
- relevant shareholder information is provided; and
- any material amounts due to or from directors and connected parties are disclosed.
Where figures are estimates, they should be reasonable estimates based upon the information available at the time.
The purpose of the Statement of Affairs is to provide creditors with a transparent and meaningful picture of the company's financial position at the commencement of the insolvency process.
Need Help Preparing a Statement of Affairs?
Preparing a Statement of Affairs can appear straightforward, but it is important that the document is prepared accurately and that all relevant assets, liabilities and creditors are properly identified.
For directors facing a Creditors' Voluntary Liquidation or Administration, we can assist with the preparation of the Statement of Affairs and guide you through the information that needs to be provided.
Our assistance can include:
- identifying the company's assets and liabilities;
- reviewing the company's accounting information;
- preparing a complete creditor listing;
- identifying secured, preferential and unsecured creditors;
- ensuring employees and former employees are properly recorded;
- identifying consumer creditors and customer deposits;
- reviewing director and connected-party balances;
- assisting with estimated realisable values;
- preparing the estimated deficiency position;
- dealing with the statutory information required for the Statement of Affairs; and
- explaining the document to directors before it is verified by statement of truth.
Where company records are incomplete, we can also explain what reasonable steps should be taken to establish the company's financial position from the information available.
Directors should not omit a creditor simply because the exact amount due is uncertain. Where a liability exists but the precise balance has not yet been established, an appropriate estimate can usually be included and subsequently updated where necessary.
If your company is insolvent or you have been asked to prepare a Statement of Affairs, contact Cromwell & Co Insolvency Practitioners for advice and assistance.
Early involvement can help ensure that the statutory requirements are dealt with correctly and that the information presented to creditors provides an accurate picture of the company's financial position.
Statement of Affairs – Frequently Asked Questions for Directors
Do I legally have to prepare a Statement of Affairs?
In a Creditors' Voluntary Liquidation, the directors have a statutory obligation to prepare a Statement of Affairs under section 99 of the Insolvency Act 1986 and the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
In an Administration, an Administrator can formally require a director or other relevant person to prepare and submit a Statement of Affairs under paragraph 47 of Schedule B1 to the Insolvency Act 1986.
It is therefore not simply a document which an Insolvency Practitioner can choose to dispense with where the statutory requirements apply.
Who is responsible for the Statement of Affairs?
In a CVL, responsibility rests with the directors.
The Insolvency Practitioner may assist with its preparation and provide the necessary format, but the information is ultimately supplied by or on behalf of the directors and the document is verified by a statement of truth.
Directors should therefore satisfy themselves that the information provided is accurate to the best of their knowledge and belief.
What if I do not know the exact amount owed to a creditor?
Not every figure will necessarily be known to the exact penny when the Statement of Affairs is prepared.
Where an exact balance cannot reasonably be established, the director should provide the best reasonable estimate available based upon the company's records and other available information.
A creditor should not be omitted simply because the precise balance is uncertain.
Do I need to include employees?
Yes.
Employees and former employees are creditors where the company owes them money.
This can include liabilities for:
- unpaid wages;
- holiday pay;
- notice pay;
- redundancy payments;
- expenses; and
- other employment-related sums.
Their claims must therefore be considered when preparing the Statement of Affairs.
Do I need to include customers who have paid deposits?
Yes.
A customer can be a creditor where they have paid money to the company and the company is unable to supply the relevant goods or services.
This can include:
- customer deposits;
- advance payments;
- prepaid subscriptions;
- unused vouchers;
- membership fees; and
- other payments made in advance.
These are commonly referred to as consumer creditors and they must be taken into account when preparing the company's creditor position.
Are employee and consumer details made public?
Not necessarily.
The Insolvency Rules provide particular protections for certain employee, former employee and consumer creditor information.
For employees and former employees, and consumers claiming amounts paid in advance for goods or services, the individual creditor particulars required by the Rules must be placed in separate schedules. Those schedules must be excluded from the version filed publicly at Companies House; the number of creditors and total debt in each category are still recorded in the statement.
However, those creditors must still be properly recorded and their claims must still be included in the financial information provided for insolvency purposes.
Does GDPR prevent me from providing creditor names and addresses?
No.
Where the Insolvency Act 1986 and Insolvency Rules require creditor information to be provided, the processing and disclosure of that information can be carried out because it is necessary to comply with a legal obligation.
Consent from each creditor is not required before their information can be used for this statutory purpose.
Normal data-protection principles still apply, including the requirement to handle information appropriately and not disclose more personal information than is required.
Can I leave a creditor off if they have not sent an invoice?
No.
The question is whether the company owes a liability, not simply whether an invoice has been received.
If the company owes money for goods, services, employment liabilities, deposits, loans or any other obligation, that liability should be considered for inclusion.
Do disputed creditors need to be included?
A disputed liability should not automatically be omitted.
Where a person asserts a claim against the company and the liability is disputed, it may still be appropriate to record the claim while making clear that it is disputed or subject to further determination.
Directors should provide the Insolvency Practitioner with details of the dispute and any supporting documentation.
Do HMRC liabilities need to be included?
Yes.
Amounts due to HM Revenue & Customs can include:
- VAT;
- PAYE;
- National Insurance contributions;
- Corporation Tax;
- CIS liabilities; and
- other tax liabilities.
Where the exact amount is not yet known, a reasonable estimate may need to be included.
Do director loan accounts need to be included?
Yes.
Where a director owes money to the company, an overdrawn director's loan account may constitute an asset of the company.
Where the company owes money to a director, the director may instead be a creditor.
Director and connected-party balances should therefore be properly identified and disclosed.
What value should I place on company assets?
A Statement of Affairs commonly shows both the book value and an estimated realisable value.
The estimated realisable value is intended to reflect what an asset may reasonably realise in the circumstances of the insolvency rather than simply the amount shown in the company's accounts.
Professional valuations may be appropriate for significant assets such as property, plant and machinery, vehicles, stock or specialist equipment.
What if the company's records are incomplete?
Incomplete accounting records do not remove the obligation to provide the required information.
Directors should take reasonable steps to reconstruct the company's financial position using available sources, which may include:
- accounting software;
- bank statements;
- VAT records;
- PAYE records;
- invoices;
- supplier statements;
- customer records;
- finance agreements;
- Companies House records; and
- correspondence with creditors.
The Insolvency Practitioner can assist in identifying the information required.
Does signing the Statement of Affairs make me personally liable for the company's debts?
No. Signing or verifying a Statement of Affairs does not, by itself, make a director personally liable for company debts.
The purpose of the statement of truth is to confirm that the information contained in the Statement of Affairs is accurate to the best of the director's knowledge and belief.
Separate issues concerning personal liability may arise in particular circumstances, but those issues are distinct from the requirement to prepare a Statement of Affairs.
What happens if information is accidentally missed?
If an omission or error is subsequently discovered, it should be brought to the Insolvency Practitioner's attention as soon as possible.
Insolvency Practitioners recognise that figures can change and additional creditors or assets can sometimes come to light after the initial Statement of Affairs has been prepared.
The important point is that directors provide information honestly and accurately based upon the information reasonably available to them.
Can I refuse to provide personal creditor information because of data protection concerns?
A director cannot ordinarily rely upon data-protection legislation as a reason for refusing to provide information which insolvency legislation requires to be supplied.
Where creditor details are required for the purposes of the statutory insolvency process, there is a lawful basis for that information to be processed.
Specific safeguards apply to certain personal information, particularly information relating to employees, former employees and consumer creditors.
Can the Insolvency Practitioner prepare the Statement of Affairs for me?
An Insolvency Practitioner and their staff can assist directors with the preparation of the Statement of Affairs, including collating information, preparing schedules and calculating the estimated deficiency.
However, the underlying information originates from the company's records and the directors, and directors remain responsible for ensuring that the information they provide is complete and accurate.
When should I start preparing the Statement of Affairs?
As early as possible.
Preparing the information in advance can help avoid delays and allows time to identify missing records, obtain creditor balances and arrange valuations where necessary.
Directors considering a CVL should therefore begin gathering the company's financial information as soon as insolvency advice is sought.
What information should I have ready?
It is helpful to have available:
- the latest management accounts;
- the company's trial balance;
- bank statements;
- aged creditor listings;
- aged debtor listings;
- HMRC balances;
- employee and payroll information;
- details of customer deposits and advance payments;
- asset registers;
- finance and hire purchase agreements;
- property details;
- stock information;
- director loan account information;
- shareholder records; and
- details of any legal claims or disputed liabilities.
If some of this information is unavailable, that does not necessarily prevent the Statement of Affairs from being prepared. We can explain what alternative information may be used.
Need advice?
If you are a director of a company which is unable to pay its debts, or you have been asked to prepare a Statement of Affairs, Cromwell & Co Insolvency Practitioners can guide you through the process and assist with the preparation of the necessary statutory information.
Seeking advice at an early stage can make the process considerably easier and help ensure that your statutory duties are dealt with correctly.
This information relates principally to corporate insolvency procedures in England and Wales and is intended as general information only. The precise statutory requirements may depend upon the insolvency procedure and the circumstances of the particular company.
